Public news or members-only content? How to split it on your website
Keep most news public, put the part members would miss behind the login, and know what WordPress restriction tools do and don't protect.
Most of your news should be public. Public stories bring readers and search engines to your site, and they show non-members what membership would give them. Members-only content should be the part a member would miss if they left: the fuller detail, the analysis for your sector, or the action members should take next. That's our view at the Desk. It isn't a rule from any regulator or plugin maker.
The split is easy to get wrong in WordPress. Restriction tools only protect what you set rules on, and some protect less than you'd assume. The rest of this guide covers how the main tools behave, and where the gaps are.
Start public, then decide what to gate
Treat public as the default and each restriction as a deliberate choice. That's also how WooCommerce Memberships works. In its documentation on restricting content, WooCommerce says content with no rules applied is publicly accessible. Once a rule is applied, that content is restricted and only open to memberships that grant access to it.
There are three ways to add those rules: while creating or editing a membership plan, from the Memberships meta box while editing a piece of content, or with a shortcode. WooCommerce says restricting from the membership plan gives the most control. So decide the split at plan level first, not post by post.
In practice, that means:
- List the kinds of story you publish, such as sector news, policy changes, event reports and guidance.
- For each kind, decide which part belongs to members. Often it's a section of the story, not the whole thing.
- Set the broad rules on the membership plan.
- Use rules on individual posts only for genuine exceptions, so you can still see the whole picture from one screen.
What the main WordPress tools can restrict
Kadence Memberships is a membership and content restriction plugin listed on WordPress.org. It lets site owners charge for access to content. It can restrict posts, pages, media, custom post types and API requests. In the free version, payment options are manual payments or Stripe. Pro adds PayPal, Authorize.net, Braintree and Custom gateways, and comes with all 34 of its add-ons. The listing doesn't give a price for Pro.
These are the plain facts from the listing that most people want before installing:
- Version 4.0.4, with 9,000+ active installations.
- Requires WordPress 6.0 or higher and PHP 7.4 or higher; tested up to 7.1.3.
- Ratings: 43 five-star, 10 four-star, 4 three-star, 1 two-star and 42 one-star.
- Support forum: 1 out of 3 issues resolved in the last two months. The forum is checked about once a week for basic troubleshooting and bug identification.
WooCommerce Memberships restricts content through the plan rules, meta box and shortcode described above. The WooCommerce documentation doesn't state pricing or licensing. Which tool suits you depends on whether you already run WooCommerce and how much support you expect.
Splitting one story into a public teaser and a members' section
A single news piece can carry both. The public part sits at the top: what has changed, who it affects, when. The members' section follows: what it means for your sector and what to do about it.
In WooCommerce Memberships 1.15 and later, the Gutenberg editor has two blocks for this. Member Content restricts what's inside it to plan members. Non-Member Content shows what's inside it to visitors and non-members.
The Member Content block has three settings. Under Membership plans, if you leave it blank, members of any plan can see the content. Delay access can open it immediately, after a length of membership or after a specific date. Restricted content message controls what others see. By default the block is invisible to people without access. A non-member reading the story won't know a members' section exists, so either set a message or add a Non-Member Content block underneath with a short note on joining. For Non-Member Content, leaving Membership plans blank means only people who don't belong to any plan see it.
If you work with shortcodes, [wcm_restrict] restricts a block of content within a page or post. It shows no restriction message. It has three optional attributes: plans, delay and start_after_trial. The plans attribute takes plan slugs or IDs, and the ID is the same as the WordPress post ID.
Pair it with [wcm_nonmember], which shows content only to guests and logged-in customers without a membership. From version 1.9, adding a plans attribute targets everyone who isn't an active member of the plans you name. One catch: a member with several memberships may see more than one message when the two shortcodes are paired to target plans. Test with an account on more than one plan before you rely on it.
Kadence Memberships has a single block, Content Upgrade Redirect.
Timed access and overlapping rules
Delayed access suits staged releases. Members might get a full briefing a week before it opens more widely, or new members might unlock the archive after a set period. The shortcode's delay attribute accepts a length of time, such as '3 days', '2 weeks', '1 month' or '2 years', or a date.
When rules overlap, WooCommerce Memberships always follows the more specific one. A rule for a single post or group of posts beats a rule for a category, and a category rule beats a rule for all posts. If two rules are equally specific, the one that grants access first wins.
The WooCommerce example makes it concrete. A post sits in two categories: 'Marvel Superheroes', which opens after two weeks, and 'Avengers', which opens after one week. The post becomes accessible in one week. If you file a story under several categories with different delays, the shortest delay decides.
The common mistake is a date with no year. A delay date such as 'May 1' may cause access to reset each year. Always include the year. Both 'January 1, 2016' and '2016-01-01' are accepted, but WooCommerce recommends the ISO format, yyyy-mm-dd.
What members-only doesn't protect
A login screen can make a site feel locked down when parts of it aren't. These are the limits the sources state:
- Kadence Memberships restricts media embedded in a post or page but doesn't protect the original file URL on the server. A members' PDF can still be reached by anyone who has its link.
- Kadence restrictions apply in REST API requests exactly as they do when viewing the site normally.
- In WooCommerce Memberships (version 1.1 and later), disabling restrictions on a piece makes it public and overrides every rule that applies to it. That content is listed on the membership plan page, so check the list there from time to time.
- A custom restriction message on an individual piece overrides the global message set under WooCommerce > Settings > Memberships > Messages. If you change the wording on joining, older custom messages won't follow.
- Products can be restricted from viewing or from purchase. Restrictions that cover many products, such as at category level, can't be edited from the product screen: they have to be changed on the plan page.
If a document must stay with members, don't rely on the post restriction alone.
Telling members a new story is up
Once you promote news by email, direct message or tracking, UK rules apply. The ICO covers several of these on its previously asked questions page.
The PECR soft opt-in currently applies only to commercial marketing. That means a not-for-profit organisation must get consent before sending promotional emails. The ICO says future changes may allow charities to rely on the soft opt-in, but that isn't the position yet.
The same page says a social media direct message containing affiliate links counts as electronic mail under PECR. If it's unsolicited, consent is usually needed, and the soft opt-in applies only to existing customers.
Adverts shown to all website users without distinction aren't direct marketing. Cookies and similar technologies still need information and consent unless they're strictly necessary, and that applies to any tracking you add to measure who reads your members' stories.
The ICO page is changing. On 16 December 2025 it added eight questions to existing sections and a new section on automated decision-making. The ICO also says its guidance is under review because of changes made by the Data (Use and Access) Act, and may change. It doesn't say when. Its Plans for new and updated guidance page sets out which guidance will be updated, so check there before you rely on any answer.
Written with AI by Corantr Media Desk from its sources' facts, checked claim by claim, and approved by a person before it was published. How we write.